Everyday Muscle

Forgo modern conveniences (such as a jack for your iPod and seat heaters), and you can find an old car that will be daily fun

So your Cobra Daytona Coupe is too hot and loud inside, and your Hemi ’Cuda convertible’s top leaks when it rains. You’d like something old yet practical as a daily driver, something you might even let your significant other or kids drive once in a while.

Anybody with a pulse and a checking account can walk into a Ford dealership today and buy a new Mustang GT, but a vintage “real” muscle car is far more fun. With a little thought and willingness to forgo modern conveniences (such as a jack for your iPod and seat heaters), you can find an old car that will be fun to live with on a daily basis.

What follows are five examples of great “all rounders.” They have ample power, handle, stop, and steer almost as well as a contemporary car—and if not, they can be made to do so with a little help.

1964½–66 Ford Mustang V8

The...