1965 Lotus Elan S2 Convertible

By on in English June 2016 issue
1965 Lotus Elan S2
Courtesy of Bonhams
Introduced at the Earls Court Motor Show in October 1962, the Elan roadster followed the Colin Chapman principle of lightweight aerodynamic coachwork coupled with the suspension, brakes and transmission of a race car, and a remarkable new Lotus-Ford twin-cam engine to provide the power. To put this into perspective, this was a time when disc brakes were still two years off for a Porsche, and Ferraris were fitted with a live rear axle. The attention from buyers and the motoring press was immediate, and Chapman quickly realized that a new factory was required to meet the demand. Full production did not start until May of 1963. With 105 horsepower on tap, light in weight and endowed with exceptional road holding and handling, the Elan would prove an immense commercial success for Lotus. Slightly fewer than 9,000 were produced by the time production ceased in 1973, of which only 1,250 were S2 models. As denoted on this car’s chassis plate, 264530 was an original North American market/U.S.-delivered car. It migrated to Canada in 1980, at which time it still wore its original brown paint scheme, albeit in need of some attention as it entered its third decade of existence. At this juncture, a comprehensive restoration was begun, and as the car was disassembled, its owner worked with the most incredible attention to detail and design, taking copious notes and design drawings, and researching each aspect while maintaining receipts for many parts acquired. As time marched on, it would actually be some 20 years before the beautifully restored rolling chassis and superbly painted body in Lotus yellow were reunited. But ultimately, owing to its owner’s death, the car was not completed. Three years ago the Elan and all the spares and parts passed into the hands of a close friend and near neighbor, Tom Munro, a master engineer and top restoration specialist based in Victoria, Vancouver Island, who finished the project in 2015. Close inspection of the car shows very fine attention to detail in both the fit and finish. The Lotus Yellow paint is immaculate, with no evidence of the common GRP body issues. Equally, the underside is very clean, and the suspension and brake components are well detailed. The chrome has been expertly replated and the interior refurbished properly to a very high standard. It comes with the original factory hard top, as well as soft top and tonneau cover. As well as its cosmetics, the mechanical aspects are reported to have been rebuilt and a new stainless-steel exhaust fitted. It could best be summarized as a true nut-and-bolt restoration. Further, the factory hard top is rather more than a pretty weather accessory, as it improves the aerodynamic punch through the air, and provides faster acceleration and better fuel economy. Chapman’s Elan is recognized universally as one of the truly great sports cars of all time, and perhaps the concluding remarks of the road test report in the February 1964 issue of Car and Driver say it best: “The Elan very simply represents the sports car developed in tune with the state of the art. It comes closer than anything else on the market to providing a formula car for ordinary street use. And it fits like a Sprite, goes like a Corvette and handles like a Formula junior.” This superb Elan is an enthusiast’s car, a driver’s car, and it is ready to deliver unique performance for rally, tour, club event or just simply as a delightful road car.

SCM Analysis

Detailing

Vehicle:1965 Lotus Elan S2 convertible
Years Produced:1964–66
Number Produced:1,250
Original List Price:$4,206
SCM Valuation:Median to date, $34,600; high sale, $60,500 (this car)
Tune Up Cost:$200
Distributor Caps:$8
Chassis Number Location:On plate riveted to left-side firewall and on the chassis
Engine Number Location:Stamped on right side of block and on chassis number plate
Club Info:Lotus Ltd.
Website:http://www.lotuscarclub.com
Alternatives:1959–74 Austin-Healey Sprite, 1962–65 Alfa Romeo Giulia Spider Veloce, 1963–68 MGB
Investment Grade:B

This car, Lot 168, sold for $60,500, including buyer’s premium, at Bonhams’ Amelia Island, FL, auction on March 10, 2016.

If you’re shopping for a quintessential British sports car of the 1960s, you might choose an E-type Jaguar, a Triumph TR4 or maybe even the last of the MGA line. But if you’re looking for the quickest and most nimble British sports car, it would be hard to do better than a Series 2 Lotus Elan.

The Elan came on the heels of the beautiful Lotus Elite, and it solidified Colin Chapman’s commitment to building cars that could be used on the road and on the race track.

Light, quick and fun

The diminutive Elan weighed just 1,515 pounds, and contemporary American road tests showed actual curb weights as low as 1,485 pounds.

The Series 2 Elan engine was based on the 1,558-cc Ford Kent block, but it has an aluminum twin-cam Lotus head on top. Induction came courtesy of dual Weber 40DCOE side-draft carburetors, and the combination was good for 105 horsepower and 108 pound-feet of torque.

Performance was impressive for the day, with a 0–60 mph time of 7.5 seconds, but where the Lotus really stood out was in its handling. With a lithe suspension at both ends, you just couldn’t beat one of these on an autocross or gymkhana course.

Not cheap fun

The retail price on the North American edition of the 1965 Elan was a steep $4,206. For comparison purposes, a sports car buyer could choose an MG Midget or Austin-Healey Sprite for about $2,000, getting 59 horsepower at a similar size and weight to the Lotus.

Spridget buyers got half the performance of the Elan for half the price. The Lotus Elan was priced competitively with the Corvette roadster, which carried a tag of $4,106, and it was more expensive than the Sunbeam Tiger at $3,499 or the Alfa Romeo Giulia Spider Veloce at $3,514. But each of these competitors hit a different mark on the performance, handling and comfort spectrum.

The Lotus Elan fit into the sports car picture as an expensive and extreme choice — much the same as Lotus cars are viewed today.

The Elan was small, spartan and quick. It renounced all creature comforts in the name of performance. This was a car designed for the club racer and track enthusiast — not for weekend getaways or highway cruising.

That explains why production figures for the Elan range from 9,659 to 12,224 units over the entire production run from 1962 to 1973. The discrepancy in production numbers is a result of the large number of cars sold as kits as a way of skirting British taxes.

The Series 2 is best

Just 1,250 examples of the Series 2 Elan were made between 1964 and 1966, so it’s fair to say that only a few hundred were made in 1965, and most of those would be U.K.-spec cars. As a North American model, the subject Elan was most likely assembled at the Lotus factory in Cheshunt, England.

Among all the Elan variants, the Series 2 Elan is the one to buy because it received several improvements made after the Series 1 cars, including the 1,558-cc engine, revised taillights and a better dashboard, but the car still remains true to the original vision.

Beginning with the Series 3 Elan, the factory made an inexplicable change to fixed side-window frames that destroy the top-down beauty of the car.

Better than factory-new

By all appearances and provenance, this Lotus Elan is about as good as you’re likely to find. Everything was restored properly, and given Lotus’ legendary build-quality issues, this car is certainly in better condition than the day it was put on the boat to America.

The yellow paint is a traditional Lotus color, but it is not original to the car. But honestly, would this car be as impressive in brown? Not a chance.

The factory hard top completes the tableau to make this a head-turning car at any show or racing event. Park it next to the row of E-Type Jags and the gaggle of various Triumph and MG models, and this Lotus will surely stand out.

At a sale price of $60,500, subtracting the auction-house premium yields a final bid price of $55,000. That’s substantially higher than the SCM Pocket Price Guide predicts, but this car is certainly worth top dollar.

The adage about buying the best car you can find applies in this case. The buyer of this Lotus will not be disappointed with the car’s potential for green appreciation — whether in cash or envy — in the years to come. ♦

(Introductory description courtesy of Bonhams.)

Written by

Jeff is a lifelong automobile enthusiast with a penchant for sports and racing cars. He has raced SCCA, local circle track, and stage rally as a co-driver. He makes his living as a freelance automotive journalist and is the author of six books on automotive topics. As a rule, he practices catch-and-release fishing when it comes to collectible automobiles, trying to leave each one in better condition than he found it. Enduring passions include his MGA and Austin Mini, and his 1969 Corvette. He recently purchased a 1920 Ford Model T Touring because “you just have to have one of these once in your life.”

Comments are closed.