Will Your Replica Be Destroyed?

John Draneas Avatar

The collector-car world was recently stunned by the news that a Swedish court awarded judgment to Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) in its copyright infringement case against Karl and Ann-Christine Magnusson. The court ruled that the Magnussons, who were in the process of building a C-type replica, had violated JLR’s copyright in the C-type form. Their replica was ordered to be destroyed and the couple also face substantial damages and attorney fee liability.

Negative reaction was swift among Jaguar enthusiasts in Europe, with descriptions such as “Jaguar — the unacceptable face of capitalism,” and “Big business crushes Swedish couple.” The outcry prompted JLR to post an open letter “to the Jaguar community” explaining its position, excerpted here:

You may have seen a recent news story relating to a C-type replica which portrays Jaguar Cars negatively… We wanted to reassure our customers and loyal enthusiasts that most of this news release was misleading, conjecture or completely untrue. At Jaguar Land Rover we wholeheartedly value our communities’ continued support. Importantly, we want to allay any fears amongst the network of enthusiasts that Jaguar Land Rover might pursue individual owners of replica Jaguars and insist upon their destruction. This is not true. We will, however, take action to stop businesses using our Intellectual Property illegally for their own profit, as in this case… We have never, nor would we, take action against private owners of pre-existing individual replica vehicles, nor insist upon the destruction of their cars. In this case Jaguar Land Rover offered the defendants an opportunity to retain their completed replica for private use and enjoyment, however, this was declined, and the defendants chose to continue with their plans to make money from our copyright.

Who are they?

Karl Magnusson and his wife, Ann-Christine, are lifelong Jaguar enthusiasts; both worked as designers in the automotive industry prior to their retirement. The Magnussons claim that they were simply building a C-type replica in their home garage for their personal use and enjoyment, and dispute being engaged in a commercial venture.

JLR and the court disagreed, pointing to the presence of a second chassis […]

With an SCM subscription, you’ll have the information, tools, and advice you need from 50+ world-renowned authorities on collector cars to make the best decisions for buying, selling and collecting classic and sports cars.

  • 18 printed issues per year: 12 monthly magazines + 6 special guides
  • 150+ printed pages every month that help you be a smarter collector
  • Access to 38 years of back issues