Drummer Gets Snared

John Draneas Avatar

My favorite rock group of all time is Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band. You can imagine my excitement, then, when drummer Max Weinberg called my office and told me he was a longtime SCMer and “a huge fan of ‘Legal Files.’” Flattering indeed, but unfortunate that we made our acquaintance because he had a problem.

“Best of the best”

A New Jersey native now living in Florida, Weinberg wanted a collector car that he could drive periodically and enter in a few shows. His search led him to Great Dane Motorsports in Pompano Beach, FL. The company is also known as Investment Automotive Group Inc. (IAG), and is run by Stuart Siegle and his son Arthur.

Weinberg visited the Siegles’ storage-locker-sized shop and saw a partially disassembled 1957 Mercedes-Benz 190SL that he was assured would be restored to a “best of the best” standard. The father-son team said they were restoring the car for sale at an upcoming Amelia Island auction, but Weinberg was told he could have it for $225,000 if he acted quickly. Feeling the pressure, he signed a contract to purchase the vehicle, and paid a $50,000 deposit.

Just days later, Arthur Siegle pressed him to pay the full contract price up front. When Weinberg refused, Stuart met with him and charmed him into paying an additional $75,000 so Siegle could “get his son off his back.” The next day, Weinberg became uncomfortable with the extra down payment, and asked Stuart Siegle to cancel the deal. Siegle refused to rescind the contract and refund the down payment.

Late on the due diligence

Weinberg hired a law firm in Boca Raton, FL, which discovered numerous lawsuits and complaints from previous customers of IAG. Concerned that he might not get the quality of car he was expecting, Weinberg retained SCM Contributor Pierre Hedary, a Mercedes expert and concours judge, to inspect the 190SL.

Hedary and Weinberg went to Siegle’s shop and inspected the car. A few days later, Hedary gave Weinberg a lengthy and highly critical report of his findings. Hedary started from the premise that, as […]

With an SCM subscription, you’ll have the information, tools, and advice you need from 50+ world-renowned authorities on collector cars to make the best decisions for buying, selling and collecting classic and sports cars.

  • 18 printed issues per year: 12 monthly magazines + 6 special guides
  • 150+ printed pages every month that help you be a smarter collector
  • Access to 38 years of back issues

2 responses to “Drummer Gets Snared”

  1. Glenn Krasner Avatar

    This is a horrific story. The only thing I can say, although it isn’t always feasible, is to try to have a qualified person inspect the car before a contract is signed. “Weinberg retained SCM Contributor Pierre Hedary, a Mercedes expert and concours judge, to inspect the 190SL.” If Mr. Weinberg had done this before a contract was signed, all this heartache and expense could have been avoided. A reputable dealer or shop will allow an inspection before a purchase, and if the car is a lemon, it can be avoided, or if still desired, a lower asking price can be negotiated. Glenn in Brooklyn, NY.

  2. AHudson777 Avatar

    Great article and great cautionary tale. Was it this one? https://bringatrailer.com/listing/1957-mercedes-benz-190sl-30/