Keith’s Blog: A Day of Cars and Boats

Last Sunday, the 25th annual Collector Car and Boat Show was held in Lake Oswego, Oregon. That’s a suburb of Portland and about fifteen minutes from my condo.

It is organized by the nonprofit Oswego Heritage Council. One-hundred percent of the proceeds go to the Council, whose mission is to preserve and interpret Lake Oswego history.

There were about 200 cars on display at George Rogers Park, and 40 boats at nearby Sundeleaf Plaza. Attendance was estimated at 5,000.

The event is casual and fun. Every entry is accepted, and the cars are arranged on the field a “first come, first served” basis. I saw no teams of straw-hatted blue-blazered judges anxiously clutching clipboards.

Shockingly, in a world of $650 concours tickets, there is no admission fee. There aren’t even parking meters on the surrounding streets.

The show includes motorcycles, and for the first time this year, historic bicycles.

My son Bradley went with me, as he is home from college between semesters.

Continuing my post-Pebble pricing PTSD, I was delighted to be able to get a latte for $5, ten caramel-dipped mini-donuts for $6, and delicious street tacos for $3 each. I tipped generously and still had change from the two $20 bills I started with.

The weather was perfect. As we strolled between the rows of cars, I was reminded both of how many ways we have invented to combine motors, bodies and wheels, and how cars draw people together.

There were a surprising number of SCM subscribers there, and I had engaging conversations with them. Our Legal Files columnist, John Draneas, showed his 1957 Alfa Romeo Giulietta Spider. He recalled I had encouraged him to buy it over a decade ago. Had found it on eBay Motors, in Scottsdale, and we were headed that way for the Barrett-Jackson Auction.

He remarked that it was one of the few smart buying decisions I have been involved with.

We also ran into good friend and English-car guru Dave Adams. He was kind enough to explain to Bradley how to tell Jaguar XK 120s, 140s and 150s apart.

As we walked by some original Minis, I told Bradley that, when he was three days old, I had brought him home from the hospital strapped in a car seat in the back of a late-model German-built Mini.

We also spent some time looking at the tidy engine bay of a very handsome, black-over-red Alfa Giulietta Spider “abnormale” owned by Ron Krueger. Born as a downdraft Solex-equipped normale, he talked Bradley through the things that he had added that are unique to a Veloce. They include forced air induction, tubular headers and dual sidedraft Webers.

We chatted with the original owner of a 1972 C3 Corvette, and contrasted it with the C3 Collector Edition that was once part of the SCM fleet.

The three cars that made an impression on me were a stunning small-bumper yellow Pantera, a long-time-owned, attractively shabby and original dark green 289 Cobra and a better-than-new restored red Fiat 850 Spider.

Best of Show went to long-time collector Commander Rand H. Wintermute, who showed his Beck 550 Spyder replica. The awards ceremony was mercifully brief (another contrast with that famous show down south) and by 2 pm we were left with the rest of the day to enjoy.

Do you have thoughts about whether it is appropriate for a replica, no matter how well executed, being awarded Best of Show? I look forward to your comments below.

Read my previous blog posts here.

Subscribe to Sports Car Market and get 12 issues, plus six Insider’s Guides, including access to our complete archive. Join here.

25 responses to “Keith’s Blog: A Day of Cars and Boats”

  1. David Andersen Avatar

    You know, that’s a good question, Keith. I supposed as long as everyone knows going in that any car entered in the show is game to be judged accordingly and possibly win “Best in Show” honors, why not? I assume they had a replica class for these cars? Replicas/recreations/tributes/kit cars (or whatever you want to call them) have been a huge part of the car hobby for decades now, and just like their “real” counterparts, they can be really good examples or not so much. Beck 550s are known to be among the best 550 Spyder replicas out there, so why penalize the owner of a really good one simply for being a replica?

    1. Keith Martin Avatar

      Thanks for the thoughtful comments. I agree with you on two points. First, everyone should know that replicas (aka tribute cars) are eligible for awards. Once that is done, a replica class could be established. Problem solved!

      1. Jim G Avatar

        Hello Keith
        Shouldn’t a Singer Porsche be considered a tribute/replica car?

        1. Keith Martin Avatar

          Good question. Singer is different as the original car was a Porsche, with a Porsche VIN number. No Beck Spyder could be correctly titled as a Porsche. A Singer is really an outlaw 911.

    2. Keith Martin Avatar

      Great comments. Yes as long as expectations line up with reality, then the more the merrier with tribute and tropical cars. And they can be judged on the quality and aesthetics of their build, not their accuracy.

    3. Keith Martin Avatar

      I don’t feel as strongly as you do. But I do think having best of show “original” and best of show “tribute” is a good idea. With original being top award.

    4. Keith Martin Avatar

      That award would be called people’s choice. With smart phones it would be easy to set that up.

    5. Keith Martin Avatar

      Thanks for the clarification. Was there an overall best of show?

    6. Keith Martin Avatar

      No replica class (I would prefer calling it “Tribute” class. I think people who own Tributes should be able to show them and be rewarded if the build deserves it.

  2. Ken Smith Avatar

    Sounds like a great show – and you can’t beat the price! It is interesting that a replica would win best of show. Just curious, as you said “I saw no teams of straw-hatted blue-blazered judges anxiously clutching clipboards”, how the beast of show was picked?

    1. Keith Martin Avatar

      A group of event organizers made the selections. Everyone seemed pleased with the choices.

  3. Captain Dave Avatar

    Absolutely not. Replica cars are like costume jewelry. Very practical to drive/wear. Not a tragedy if it’s damaged/lost. And if you have the real one at home in the garage/safe, then it’s not cheating. The word “tribute” indicates respectful acknowledgement of someone else’s achievement. Hat’s off to caring enough about something to commission a replica or tribute car. “Honorable Mention” is a traditional category that is appropriate for such cars, and promotes awareness of the interesting stories of their creation. But to put a replica up for judging next to a painstakingly restored pre- or even post-war Packard is disrespectful of the car, its owner, the craftsmen who restored it and the hobby at large.

    1. David Henkel Avatar

      I agree completely with Captain Dave. Well stated.

  4. Bob FitzSimons Avatar

    I have a replica- actually two. For the last 2 months, I’ve driven a VW based Frazer-Nash kit car nearly daily. I tell people it’s a beetle in a halloween costume. I point out the slightly awkward trunk that houses the engine. Sometimes I show them the “frunk”. Civilians are not offended by it.

    To judge replicas in car shows, you have to be clear what your criteria are. If it’s looks, or cleanliness, or pleasing arrangement of the interior, a replica can hold its own. If you’re looking for originality, or signs of hand craftsmanship, such as ash frame members and beaten body panels, then most replicas are in trouble, but maybe not the odd home built “tribute”. In the case of the kit cars with radiator shells and no radiators, some people might draw a line.

    What about resto mods? What about the Morgan I saw listed recently with fiberglass fenders?

    I think the difficulty comes when we start assigning moral values or virtue points to aspects of cars. Not long ago, I saw a red Ferrarri that was being touted as having come from the factory with green paint. The lucky buyer could re-do the paint and have a more distinctive car that would also be factory-correct. Unlike the poor soul who had to live with the factory-wrong red, or, God forbid, the sinner who painted a factory-red car green. Is this any way to live?

  5. Frank Barrett Avatar

    The most enjoyable car shows delete judging altogether. That way, a guy with a less than perfect yet interesting car is not hesitant to show it. Local shows like the one you mention are a welcome respite from the overblown and overpriced “concours d’elegance”. I stopped going to Monterey because it was too expensive and too crowded; many others say the same thing.

  6. Frank T Avatar

    To eliminate such disputes just have entrants vote on the cars only…That way you can’t call bias or friends of judges or show promotors…

    1. Keith Martin Avatar

      Luckily it’s a big tent and there is room for everyone.

  7. Participant Avatar

    The Oswego Heritage Council owes participants an apology. A turn-key replica as best of show is a joke. I know of participants who have shown their cars many times that never expected an award, but have loved showing their cars. Every car showed has now been disrespected. Why show your car to be indirectly insulted. Showing a replica is fine, but not an award. A designated replica award would be OK. Whoever is responsible for the selection of the replica as Best of Show subscribed to a lot of BS. Keith, a great blog.

    1. Rand Wintermute Avatar

      Please be reminded that the LO car “ Show” is NOT a Concours event by Class Judging Standards ; the Show Awards are Based SOLEY on “Popularity” by all the Attendees !
      It was stated by the LO Board in their vote tabulation sticker turned in by everyone who voted .

  8. John Clemson Avatar

    Keith, he won Best of show for “open cars.” He’s having fun with it and that’s what’s important although he probably should refer to it as a Beck.

    I’ve been to and have entered many cars in the Oswego Heritage show including my Porsche 356, my 76 GMC Square Body, 66 Mustang , and 86 El Camino that I restored myself. All were well received and many folks stopped by to discuss them. It’s a great show. My goal is to have my under restoration 66 Antique Bronze Mustang there next year.

  9. Truman McGhee Avatar

    I’m with Participant and Captain Dave.

    1. Keith Martin Avatar

      Thanks for the long and thoughtful response. As to the Healey, if you have always wanted one, now is the time to buy as they are half price.

  10. Tom Clarke Avatar

    I had to think about this for a while and ruminate about the various comments. Is the Beck fiberglass or aluminum/steel? There are some real abominations out there as far as replicas go, like some of the fiberglass Porsche speedsters and Austin Healey 3000 knockoffs. But Even some original Ferraris are plastic, so maybe that should not be a consideration.

    (BTW Keith, I’m jealous of your recent purchase of the Healey you bought for $30k. I have lusted after one for years. I used to navigate for my cousin when we rallied in his ’65 3000 Mark III. and can still hear that great booming exhaust. I have a somewhat modern day equivalent in my ’98 BMW M Roadster, which I have driven for 166,000 delightful miles without any problems. All original, including the clutch. But I would love to have a Healey.)

    Back to the question. I just talked to my sweetheart, whom I have spent almost 30 years turning into an appreciator of fun automobiles, and she agrees with the conclusion that I reached. The Beck should have received a best in show if compared to other replicas, but not when compared to originals. Do you think the manufacturer of replica 1930’s blower Bentleys will ever win a Best in Show at one of the more renowned concours? I don’t think so. There’s a reward for the care that goes into restoring an maintaining historic cars, and replicas should not be honored above original entrants.

    In regards to your comment about $650 tickets for the Pebble, I have gone to six or seven Pebble Beach Concours, and agree it has become very expensive, but a significant portion of the money goes to support charities. For free or reasonable entertainment during car week in Monterey area, go to the British only show in Carmel Valley (free), the Mecum auction ($30), the Gooding Auction preview ($50), and a lot of other free or reasonably-priced venues. The truly outrageously expensive event is The Quail at almost $1500. I went twice when it was still under $500, but you can only eat and drink and eyeball so much, so I can’t justify the expense, and I don’t believe it’s a charitable event.

  11. Rand Wintermute Avatar

    To all who commented on Keith’s question of
    Replica cars winning a “Best of Show” category , please note I was surprised MORE then anyone that my Beck 550 Spyder was chosen “ Best in Class “ for “Open Cars” last Sunday at the LO car show. , as I voted for John Dranius’s cute red 1957 Alfa Spyder !….as a former Forest Grove “Porsche class” Judge , the Award to my 550 was a complete surprise . However, having shown it at many Monterey Week Concours events the previous week, I became aware of the 550 popularity , with its timeless design and Race history , which saved Porsche from bankruptcy in 1954. It should be known that Beck still manufacturers the type 550 of FG, with a 3 year waiting list on new orders and a price now of over $ 100K per car, depending on the engine type. As a long time Porsche Collector, and former Concours Judge, I bought my Beck 550 Spyder due to the History of this great Porsche car design, albeit a Superbly built replica….for me personally, the Historical significance of the 550 is paramount ! It SHOULD be recognized at EVERY Porsche event for its Race history and iconic design; sadly , the late James Dean never got to race his # 130 in Salinas on that fateful day !

  12. Rand Wintermute Avatar

    A further comment , it should be reminded to everyone who follow Classic cars and Concours Class Judging , that the Lake Oswego Car show IS NOT an actual “Concours Class” event , but that the Car Show awards are BASED on “ popularity “ of the “Attendees” of this event . Therefore, popularity is based “On the eyes of the Beholders” ! With the LO Car Show, there are no standards to compare each car to, so “Popularity” of a particular car will win the Awards. It is NOT based on any particular “Class Judging Merit”,
    so this is very important to distinguish from a real “Classic Car Concours”, which is always
    “Merit Based”, on original Factory standards !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.