Revology 1968 Shelby GT350. Image courtesy of Revology.
“Restoration” and “replacement” can be one and the same
There is always a surprise at Arizona Auction Week. I invariably run into something or someone that is both interesting and unexpected. This year, it was Revology Mustangs.
Revology is the brainchild of Tom Scarpello, a retired auto executive who set out to build modern cars that have the styling of the original Mustang. When he was at Ford Motor Company, he was always asked why it didn’t build more original Mustangs, as everyone wanted one. That wasn’t interesting to Ford, but Scarpello held onto the idea as something he would get into himself in the future.
Scarpello formed Revology in 2014. He says they started out restoring Mustangs but found that to be too difficult. “We were always finding rust or improper repairs everywhere we went, which made it hard and expensive to achieve the results we were looking for,” he said. “So, we decided it would be better to just start from scratch and build our own cars.”
Every body part for a vintage Mustang is readily available from Ford-licensed manufacturers, built to original specifications. Revology uses these parts to construct a perfect body shell. It then adds modern suspension components, your choice of a 460-horsepower Ford Coyote motor or a Roush-modified and supercharged motor that makes 710 horses, a manual or automatic transmission, restyled interior components, and their proprietary-design door hinges that make the doors shut just like a modern car. Finished to your specifications, the car looks just like a perfectly restored vintage Mustang, but it drives more like a modern car. It is made of entirely new components except for one original Ford Mustang part — more on that below.
Pricing is based upon the model and your chosen specs, but the range is generally $280,000 to $380,000. There are about 300 Revology Mustangs on the road today and a lengthy wait list for the approximately six cars per month that the company is currently able to build. Revology is licensed by both Ford and Shelby.
[…]
Revology 1968 Shelby GT350. Image courtesy of Revology.
“Restoration” and “replacement” can be one and the same
There is always a surprise at Arizona Auction Week. I invariably run into something or someone that is both interesting and unexpected. This year, it was Revology Mustangs.
Revology is the brainchild of Tom Scarpello, a retired auto executive who set out to build modern cars that have the styling of the original Mustang. When he was at Ford Motor Company, he was always asked why it didn’t build more original Mustangs, as everyone wanted one. That wasn’t interesting to Ford, but Scarpello held onto the idea as something he would get into himself in the future.
Scarpello formed Revology in 2014. He says they started out restoring Mustangs but found that to be too difficult. “We were always finding rust or improper repairs everywhere we went, which made it hard and expensive to achieve the results we were looking for,” he said. “So, we decided it would be better to just start from scratch and build our own cars.”
Every body part for a vintage Mustang is readily available from Ford-licensed manufacturers, built to original specifications. Revology uses these parts to construct a perfect body shell. It then adds modern suspension components, your choice of a 460-horsepower Ford Coyote motor or a Roush-modified and supercharged motor that makes 710 horses, a manual or automatic transmission, restyled interior components, and their proprietary-design door hinges that make the doors shut just like a modern car. Finished to your specifications, the car looks just like a perfectly restored vintage Mustang, but it drives more like a modern car. It is made of entirely new components except for one original Ford Mustang part — more on that below.
Pricing is based upon the model and your chosen specs, but the range is generally $280,000 to $380,000. There are about 300 Revology Mustangs on the road today and a lengthy wait list for the approximately six cars per month that the company is currently able to build. Revology is licensed by both Ford and Shelby.
It’s a “restoration”
Going into new-car manufacture is not an easy task, so Revology sidesteps these regulatory nightmares by qualifying its cars as restorations. Each of its Mustangs starts out as a real, vintage, licensed Mustang donor car, either provided by the buyer or sourced by Revology. The donor car gets titled in your state of choice, and then goes to Revology for “restoration.”
This is conducted by cutting the chassis plate out of the donor car — the sole original part used — and installing it in the new body created by Revology. Then, voilà! You have a newly restored vintage Mustang that is legitimately registered as the original donor car. No crash tests, no emissions testing, just ready to drive and enjoy.
Whether this is legal is a fair question. How can this be a “restoration” when the only original part is the chassis plate? But all lawyers know that common sense is often not what determines the answers to legal questions.
Say the problem with the donor car was that the front end had been badly crashed. So you weld a new front clip into the car, saving the chassis-plate portion, and throw in a modern engine for better performance. Is that still legitimately the donor car? I’m sure everyone agrees it is. After a while, you decide to replace the rear clip. Still the same car? A while later, you replace the floorboard, roof and doors, as well as the rest of the drivetrain. Now, the only original part you have is the chassis plate. Is it still the same car? If it isn’t, exactly when in the process did the car stop being the donor car? And if the piecemeal restoration approach works, why is the answer different if you just do it all at once?
Theseus and Washington
This authenticity conundrum is nothing new. Several thousand years ago, Theseus developed hero status as a Greek warrior. The Athenians decided to honor him by preserving his ship for all time. Unfortunately, the elements were not kind. As the ship’s planks decayed, the Athenians carefully and sensitively replaced them one by one, with perfectly crafted replacements. Eventually, none of the original planks remained. Plutarch then posed the question, “Is this still the ship of Theseus?”
Lest you think this was just some sort of mind game dreamed up by my ancestors, we also have the more-recent version, the apocryphal story of the curator in an American museum leading a tour and proudly stopping at a climate-controlled display of the museum’s prized possession, George Washington’s axe. “Of course,” he explains, “we’ve replaced the head twice and the handle three times, but this is still the same axe that George Washington swung with his very hands.”
This can be a slippery slope. There are many examples of someone “resurrecting” wrecked cars by “rebodying” them. There are a number of valuable collector cars that were created when their manufacturers modified more-pedestrian street cars. Think Porsche 911 Carrera RS 2.7 vs. base 911, or Pontiac GTO vs. LeMans. But since we’re on the subject of Mustangs, consider the numerous examples of rebodied Shelby GT350s. Carroll Shelby started with a base Mustang, modified its drivetrain and suspension components, and added some badging. It took a lot of talent and creativity for Shelby to do that the first time, but anyone can do it today with readily available parts.
You can start with the remains of a wrecked GT350 that is beyond repair. Find a donor Mustang in good condition and swap chassis plates. Take whatever useful GT350 parts there are, if any, and then buy the rest in the marketplace. Put them all into the donor Mustang, add all the GT350 badging, and you now have the functional equivalent of the pre-crash GT350. If you do a really good job, it might take an expert to tell the difference.
Don’t have a wrecked GT350? Go to the registries or other sources and identify a GT350 whose whereabouts are unknown — wrecked beyond repair, stolen and never recovered or just disappeared. Track down the last registered owner, buy the car from him, and get it titled in your name. Now, you are the owner of the missing GT350. Make your own chassis plate, make it look old, and then put it into a donor Mustang chassis and make it a GT350 as previously described. These are called “air cars,” in the sense that they are made out of thin air.
When is it a scam?
As you might have noticed, there isn’t a huge difference between what the scammers are doing and what Revology is doing. However, there is one huge difference — what the finished product is represented to be.
Those who “rebody” wrecked cars or build air cars see provenance and authenticity as some sort of intangible right that one can own and bestow on any tangible thing they want. In their view, they own the rights to the chassis number, and they can attach it to any appropriate car they choose. Once they do, that makes their car the “original” one. Thus, they represent the finished car as actually being the car with the original chassis number, even when the chassis plate is the only thing that may have ever touched the original body.
In contrast, everyone who buys a Revology Mustang knows that they are buying a brand-new car, built from scratch, that just looks like the original donor car. Neither Revology nor the buyer see it as being the donor car. The only reason the donor car’s chassis plate is affixed is so that it can be titled and registered.
If anyone is fooled, it is the state. But the states are hard pressed to do much about this because of the piecemeal restoration example given above. When you can’t pinpoint when the car became a different car, there isn’t much ground for objection.
Leave a Reply