Your automotive acquisition is safely ensconced on a transporter and on its way home — or is it?
Sophisticated thieves have figured out a new hack to steal your car
“Phil,” an avid East Coast car collector, had decided he wanted a modern supercar that was difficult to source. (Since this is an active case, we can’t identify the car.) He found one offered by a dealer in the middle of the country that had the options he wanted. The deal was struck, and Phil wired the full purchase price to the dealer, who was happy to arrange transport — at Phil’s cost, of course.
The dealer contacted a transport broker that he had used many times previously. The transport broker sent the order to a transport company it selected, which accepted the contract. A few days later, the transport company arrived at the dealer and picked up the car. The dealer called Phil and advised him that his new toy was on its way and would be there in three days.
Three days came and went, but with no car. Phil called the dealer, who called the transport broker, who called the transport company. “What order? We don’t know what you’re talking about.”
A frenzied investigation discovered that the transport company’s computer had been hacked. The thieves intercepted the transport order, deleted it from the transport company’s computer, and sent one of their people to pick it up. The truck and trailer displayed the transport company’s name, the driver wore a shirt with the transport company’s logo, and he had all the proper paperwork. No one had any reason to suspect anything.
But the car was gone.
Insurance woes
A bad situation quickly became much worse. Phil had used a familiar consumer insurance company for many years, but had come to realize that he would be better off using a collector car insurance company. He applied for coverage for his entire collection, including the new addition. The application successfully went through underwriting and, after some discussions about policy coverages and limits, the policy was issued. Phil was somewhat embarrassed […]
Your automotive acquisition is safely ensconced on a transporter and on its way home — or is it?
Sophisticated thieves have figured out a new hack to steal your car
“Phil,” an avid East Coast car collector, had decided he wanted a modern supercar that was difficult to source. (Since this is an active case, we can’t identify the car.) He found one offered by a dealer in the middle of the country that had the options he wanted. The deal was struck, and Phil wired the full purchase price to the dealer, who was happy to arrange transport — at Phil’s cost, of course.
The dealer contacted a transport broker that he had used many times previously. The transport broker sent the order to a transport company it selected, which accepted the contract. A few days later, the transport company arrived at the dealer and picked up the car. The dealer called Phil and advised him that his new toy was on its way and would be there in three days.
Three days came and went, but with no car. Phil called the dealer, who called the transport broker, who called the transport company. “What order? We don’t know what you’re talking about.”
A frenzied investigation discovered that the transport company’s computer had been hacked. The thieves intercepted the transport order, deleted it from the transport company’s computer, and sent one of their people to pick it up. The truck and trailer displayed the transport company’s name, the driver wore a shirt with the transport company’s logo, and he had all the proper paperwork. No one had any reason to suspect anything.
But the car was gone.
Insurance woes
A bad situation quickly became much worse. Phil had used a familiar consumer insurance company for many years, but had come to realize that he would be better off using a collector car insurance company. He applied for coverage for his entire collection, including the new addition. The application successfully went through underwriting and, after some discussions about policy coverages and limits, the policy was issued. Phil was somewhat embarrassed to report the theft, as the policy ink wasn’t dry yet, but here he was making a substantial claim.
Embarrassment turned to shock when the insurance company told him there was no coverage. The new policy was issued, but the car had been picked up by the fraudulent shipping company two days earlier. Since the policy was issued after the car had been stolen, there was no coverage.
Phil couldn’t believe that, as he had applied for the new insurance coverage well before any of this, and it was the insurance company that had delayed matters with its underwriting process. He asked for a review, which eventually resulted in a final determination that there was no coverage.
Phil then filed a claim on his existing consumer policy. After all, it provided for automatic coverage of any new car he might acquire. That claim was also denied. Automatic coverage is provided, but you have to inform the insurance company of the new purchase and add the new car to the policy within 30 days of purchase. Phil missed that deadline because he was still waiting for the collector car insurance company to make a final determination on coverage. This seems like a catch-22 — the loss occurred during that 30-day window, so it would seem that coverage should be provided.
Unexpected miracle
As Phil was trying to figure out who to sue, he received an unexpected phone call: The Los Angeles police had found his car!
LAPD had been involved in a major drug trafficking investigation and identified an East Los Angeles warehouse that was believed to be the center of the drug operation. When they raided the warehouse, they found not only the drugs but also 12 expensive new cars, including Phil’s, now with 250 miles on the odometer.
Apparently, the theft ring would grind down the serial numbers on the stolen cars, replace them with fake VINs, get the cars titled, and then resell them as low-mileage supercars. Fortunately, Phil’s car had just gotten to the warehouse and the process had not yet started when it was found.
All may be well if it ends well, but Phil doesn’t know what might have happened during those 250 miles. The police were not able to confirm the condition of the car, so Phil will be flying to L.A. soon.
Not an aberration
Phil said that the police told him this sort of thing happens every day. I know of another case in which a small collector car dealer was similarly victimized. He sold a car to a distant buyer, who asked him to arrange transport. The dealer called a broker he had used before and… well, you know the rest of the story.
In this case, both the dealer and the buyer have insurance. The dealer’s insurance company denied his claim on the basis that the car had already been sold to the buyer when it was picked up by the phony transporter, so the dealer did not suffer a loss. The buyer’s insurance company is arguing the opposite, so it may take a while, but eventually the buyer will be made whole once the insurance carriers settle.
That will likely turn on technical legal issues such as when ownership of the car — and risk of loss — passed to the buyer. Whichever insurance company winds up paying, it will undoubtedly look to recoup its loss from whoever it can assess blame against.
Who’s responsible?
In both cases, the likely target is the transport broker. After all, the broker accepted the order and promised to transport the car. However, brokers routinely tell their customers that their job is to find a transport company to provide the service. They can be expected to claim that they did their job and, unless it can be shown that they were negligent in their selection of the transport company, they shouldn’t be responsible for the loss.
The other parties can argue that the transport contract was entered into with the transport broker, and the shipping company is a subcontractor, so the broker remains liable. But the disclosure that all the broker is doing is finding a shipper goes against that, and the broker also has the defense that it didn’t do anything wrong.
Another obvious target is the shipping company. Its defense is going to be that it never accepted the order, and it wasn’t its fault that it got hacked. People can argue about whether the company took appropriate cyber-security measures, but otherwise it’s hard to see it being held liable on a job it never knew anything about.
That leaves us with the dealer. One view is that the dealer never delivered the car to the buyer — it was delivered to the wrong person. From that perspective, the buyer never received possession of the car, and the dealer still owes it to him. The other angle is that the dealer should have used a different transport broker. But again, unless the dealer was negligent in selecting an unqualified broker, that may not fly. Plus, the loss had nothing to do with the capabilities of the broker.
These difficult legal questions about liability can take years to resolve, and underscore how it is essential that you know you have adequate insurance coverage before anyone even starts to think about moving your car.
Lessons learned
It seems pretty clear that using a transport broker injects another element of risk into the car-transport transaction. Bob Sellers, Vice President/COO of Reliable Carriers, explained, “Once you engage a transport broker, you relinquish control over the transport. You aren’t talking to the carrier — only to the broker.”
Additionally, the nature of the brokerage relationship lends itself to increased risk. “The broker is looking to earn a profit on the transaction. The profit is the difference between what you pay and what the shipper is paid. The larger the difference, the larger the profit. The broker’s incentive is to find the lowest-cost shipper possible. Of course, that increases all sorts of risks,” said Sellers.
To get a handle on the economics here, I asked him what the cost difference can be between going through a broker and directly engaging a reputable carrier. “It depends on a lot of things, the distance, the car, the timing,” he said. “But generally, the price difference may be as little as $200 and as much as $1,000 on a cross-country haul.”
In some situations, $200 is a lot to save. But in cases where cars are in the six-figure value range, even a $1,000 difference in transport cost is a drop in the bucket.
So play it safe. Spend a little more, use a reputable transport company, and sleep better at night.
Leave a Reply