Who Hit Whom?

Legal Files - January 2027
John Draneas Avatar

Accident reconstruction can establish the truth after a car collision This month’s “Legal Files” brings back memories for both me and Publisher Martin. We were born three months apart and grew up on opposite sides of Golden Gate Park in San Francisco, in the area known as “The Avenues.” We went to rival high schools, and we both ended up in Portland, where we met and became fast friends some 35 years ago. The Avenues were laid out in a rigid grid pattern. The non-arterial intersections were totally unprotected, and car crashes were a common occurrence. We’d hear a skid, then a loud crash, and we’d run outside to see how mangled the cars were. Today, stop signs and traffic signals have largely solved the problem, but not entirely. Non-stop “Tom” was driving his Honda SUV, descending Potrero Hill’s roughly 20% grade. When he came to the intersection at the bottom, he saw that the traffic signals were inoperative, making it a four-way stop. Tom stopped, did not see any cross traffic, and started off. He made it to the middle of the intersection when he was broadsided by a Porsche Cayenne driven by “Hurley” that entered the intersection from his right without stopping. The considerable force of the impact pushed Tom about 40 feet away and rolled his Honda onto its top. As we know, there are always at least two sides to every story. Hurley told a similar story, except the roles were reversed. He stopped completely at the intersection, checked for cross traffic, accelerated, and then was surprised as Tom failed to stop and appeared in his path, leaving him no time to stop. Lawsuit filed Tom was injured and filed suit to recover damages for his medical injuries and the damage to the Honda. Hurley was incredulous that he was being sued, as the crash was all Tom’s fault. Lawyer SCMers know that litigants often have wildly different versions of what happened. Witnesses can be helpful in establishing who did what; unfortunately, we didn’t have any here. Physical evidence can be critical and decisive, but there…

With an SCM subscription, you’ll have the information, tools, and advice you need from 50+ world-renowned authorities on collector cars to make the best decisions for buying, selling and collecting classic and sports cars.

  • 18 printed issues per year: 12 monthly magazines + 6 special guides
  • 150+ printed pages every month that help you be a smarter collector
  • Access to 38 years of back issues

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.